Every writer eventually meets them: the villain who should be terrifying… but somehow lands closer to awkward karaoke act than dark overlord. On paper, they’re ruthless. On the page? They twirl a metaphorical moustache, make dramatic speeches, and then inexplicably allow the hero to escape for reasons.
If that sounds familiar, you’re not alone. I’ve spent twenty years writing fiction and reading drafts where the antagonist is meant to be a force of nature—yet they feel like a breeze you could shrug off with a cardigan.
The good news? Scariness isn’t magic. It’s craft. And with a few deliberate choices, you can transform a cardboard cut-out villain into the character your readers whisper about at 2am.
Let’s talk about why your villain might not be as frightening as you want—and how to fix it.
1. Your Villain Has Motives… But No Logic
A scary villain doesn’t just do bad things. They have reasons—and those reasons make sense to them.
A flat villain thinks like this:
“I am evil because the script demands it.”
A terrifying villain thinks like this:
“What I’m doing is necessary—and if you understood the world the way I do, you would agree.”
When readers can trace the logic—even if they reject it morally—they feel a chill. Because they can see how close that path might be.
Ask yourself:
- Can you explain your villain’s worldview in one compelling sentence?
- If you gave them the microphone for five minutes, would they sound unhinged—or uncomfortably reasonable?
If their motives don’t line up with their actions, fix the logic first. Ruthlessness built on coherent reasoning is far more unnerving than random cruelty.
2. You Tell Us They’re Dangerous—But Don’t Show It
Writers love to tell us how feared a villain is. Everyone whispers. Entire villages tremble. People refuse to say their name.
And then… the villain pops on-screen and does nothing more dangerous than frowning and issuing idle threats.
Fear needs proof.
We need to see:
- Consequences of crossing them
- Evidence of past brutality
- The quiet hints that this is someone you should never underestimate
That doesn’t mean gore. Subtext is powerful. A character who never raises their voice but makes everyone step aside? Terrifying.
So don’t announce danger. Demonstrate it.
Let your reader witness the moment a character misjudges the villain—and pays for it.
3. Your Villain Has No Real Power
A villain is only as scary as the power imbalance they create.
If the hero can walk away from every encounter unscathed, the villain feels like a minor inconvenience—an unusually rude barista, perhaps, but not an existential threat.
Power comes in many forms:
- Social power
- Emotional manipulation
- Financial control
- Knowledge
- A loyal network
- The law
- Charisma
- Reputation
A villain who controls something the hero needs becomes instantly magnetic.
Give your villain leverage. Let them pull strings the hero can’t even see.
4. Your Villain Is Predictable
Predictable villains are safe villains. We may not like them, but we don’t fear them—because we can anticipate their moves.
A frightening villain breaks the pattern.
Not randomly—that reads as chaotic rather than chilling—but strategically. They do things your reader didn’t see coming… until they realise the signs were there all along.
Think of the moment when the audience says:
“Oh no. They wouldn’t… would they?”
And then they do.
Predictability is the enemy of tension. Let your villain surprise you first.
5. Your Villain Exists Only To Oppose the Hero
If your villain disappears when the protagonist leaves the room, you don’t have a character. You have a prop.
A great villain has:
- A life beyond the plot
- Goals that don’t revolve around the hero
- A story that was already happening before page one
They aren’t a shadow trailing your protagonist—they are the centre of their own narrative.
And when those two stories collide? That’s where sparks—and fear—begin.
6. Your Villain Isn’t Human Enough
Ironically, one of the quickest ways to make a villain less scary is to make them pure evil. When they have no humanity, we disengage. There’s nothing recognisable. Nothing to project onto. Nothing to fear becoming.
The scariest villains are the ones we see reflected in ourselves—the parts we might become under different circumstances.
A hesitation.
A moment of kindness.
A sliver of vulnerability.
These don’t redeem them. They ground them. And grounded evil feels like it could walk right into our world.
7. Your Hero Never Loses
If your hero wins every confrontation, the villain becomes background noise.
Let the hero fail.
Let them misjudge.
Let them pay a price.
A villain who changes the hero is far more memorable than one who merely inconveniences them. They force the protagonist to grow—sometimes into someone they don’t want to be.
Fear lives in risk.
Raise the stakes. And then raise them again.
8. Your Villain Talks Too Much
Nothing pops the tension balloon faster than a villain monologue.
If your antagonist explains every plan, every thought, every scar from childhood… the mystery collapses.
Silence is powerful.
Restraint is chilling.
Let the reader fill some gaps.
Let the villain keep secrets.
Fear thrives in the unknown.
9. You Haven’t Thought About Their Voice
A villain’s dialogue isn’t scary because they shout or threaten. It’s scary because of how they use language.
Do they:
- Speak with unsettling calm?
- Offer compliments that feel like traps?
- Use formal politeness as a weapon?
- Avoid answering questions directly?
Tone matters. Rhythm matters. What they don’t say matters.
Craft their voice with intent. Let it linger.
10. Your Villain Doesn’t Believe They’re the Villain
Here’s the truth I’ve learned after two decades of writing fiction:
The best villains do not think of themselves as villains.
They believe:
- They’re fixing a broken world
- They deserve what they’re taking
- They were wronged first
- They had no other choice
- They’re the hero of a story that happens to oppose yours
And sometimes? They’re persuasive.
Which is exactly why they’re frightening.
Practical Exercises to Make Your Villain Scarier
Let’s get hands-on.
Exercise 1: Write Their Manifesto
Give your villain 500 words to explain why they’re right. No moustache twirling. Make the argument painful to dismiss.
Exercise 2: Remove One Speech
Find a scene where your villain explains themselves.
Cut the explanation.
Rewrite the scene using actions alone.
Exercise 3: Give Them a Win
Write a chapter where the villain wins decisively.
How does the hero change as a result?
Exercise 4: The Human Moment
Write a quiet scene unrelated to the plot where your villain:
- cooks
- feeds a pet
- reads
- talks to a child
- sits alone
Don’t redeem them.
Just reveal them.
Exercise 5: Shift Perspective
Write one scene entirely from your villain’s POV.
Let the reader feel what they feel.
Make it make sense.
Fear Is About Imbalance
Ultimately, a villain becomes frightening when they disturb the balance of the story—and the inner balance of the reader.
They make us question:
- What we might do in their place
- Whether the hero is strong enough
- Whether goodness can stand against determination
A great villain works like a mirror and a storm at once. They reflect something human—and then tear through the narrative with undeniable force.
So if your villain isn’t scary yet?
Good.
It means you’re paying attention.
It means you care.
And it means you’re already halfway to creating someone unforgettable.
Now… go sharpen their edges.
Dialogue is one of those slippery beasts in fiction. Get it right and your characters breathe — they walk into a room, speak, and suddenly . . .
There comes a point — usually somewhere between draft number three and “why am I doing this to myself?” — when writing stops feeling like . . .
There’s a peculiar moment every writer knows. You open the email, or the message, or the comments. You know what’s inside. Feedback. Critique. Notes. You . . .
There’s a quiet ache that lives inside a lot of would-be writers. It sounds like this: I want to write. I really do. But I . . .