Plot vs. Character – Which Should Writers Prioritise?

April 20, 2024

Tags: Active voice vs passive voice, Better writing skills, Common writing errors, Developing your writing voice, Differing views on writing, Finding your writing style, First person vs third person, Grammar guidelines, Grammar mistakes to avoid, Grammar rules, How to improve your writing, Improving writing style, Literary devices to use and avoid, Present tense vs past tense, Proper grammar, Proper punctuation, Punctuation mistakes to avoid, Punctuation tips, Rhetorical devices, Stylistic writing debates, Writing advice, Writing best practices, Writing controversies, Writing conundrums, Writing debates, Writing dilemmas, Writing grammar rules, Writing guidelines, Writing mistakes to avoid, Writing opinions, Writing perspectives, Writing rules, Writing style advice, Writing style tips, Writing stylistic choices, Writing tips

In the vast and diverse landscape of literature, writers often find themselves at a crossroads: should they prioritise crafting intricate plots that keep readers on the edge of their seats, or should they focus on developing rich and complex characters that readers can connect with on a deeper level? This age-old debate has fuelled discussions among writers, critics, and readers alike, each side presenting compelling arguments for their preferred approach. In this article, we’ll delve into the nuances of the plot versus character debate, exploring the merits and challenges of each perspective to help aspiring authors navigate this fundamental question in their own writing journey.

The Primacy of Plot:

Proponents of prioritizing plot argue that a compelling storyline is the backbone of any successful work of fiction. They emphasize the importance of crafting intricate plots with twists and turns that keep readers engaged from beginning to end. For these writers, the plot serves as the driving force behind the narrative, providing the framework upon which all other elements of the story are built.

One of the key advantages of prioritizing plot is its ability to create tension and suspense, drawing readers into the story and keeping them hooked until the very last page. A well-executed plot can take readers on a rollercoaster ride of emotions, leaving them eager to discover what happens next.

Furthermore, proponents of plot-centric writing argue that a strong plot can compensate for shortcomings in other areas, such as character development. Even if the characters are not fully fleshed out, a gripping plot can still captivate readers and keep them invested in the story.

The Power of Character:

On the other side of the debate are those who champion the importance of character development above all else. These writers argue that memorable characters are the heart and soul of any great story, and that readers are more likely to connect with well-rounded characters than they are with a convoluted plot.

Character-driven writers emphasize the importance of creating characters who feel authentic and relatable, with hopes, fears, and flaws that readers can empathize with. They believe that by focusing on developing compelling characters, writers can create stories that resonate on a deeper emotional level, leaving a lasting impact on readers long after they’ve finished the book.

Furthermore, proponents of character-driven writing argue that strong characters have the potential to drive the plot forward in more meaningful and organic ways. When characters are fully developed and three-dimensional, their actions and decisions naturally propel the story forward, creating a sense of authenticity and realism that can be difficult to achieve through plot alone.

Finding the Balance:

While the debate between plot and character may seem dichotomous, many writers argue that the key to successful storytelling lies in finding the right balance between the two. Rather than viewing plot and character as competing elements, these writers advocate for an approach that integrates both aspects seamlessly, allowing them to complement and enhance each other.

One way to achieve this balance is to use the plot as a vehicle for character development, allowing the events of the story to shape and transform the characters over time. Conversely, writers can use the traits and motivations of their characters to drive the plot forward in ways that feel organic and true to the story.

Ultimately, whether a writer chooses to prioritise plot or character depends on the specific needs of their story and their personal writing style. Some stories may lend themselves more naturally to a plot-driven approach, while others may require a deeper focus on character development. The key is for writers to remain open to experimentation and to be willing to adapt their approach as needed to serve the needs of their story.

In the end, the debate between plot and character is not about declaring one approach superior to the other, but rather about recognizing the unique strengths and challenges of each perspective. Both plot and character play vital roles in the storytelling process, and the most successful writers are those who are able to harness the power of both to create compelling and memorable works of fiction. By understanding the nuances of this debate and finding the right balance between plot and character, aspiring authors can elevate their writing to new heights and captivate readers with stories that linger long after the final page.